Choosing the Best Tenant When Applications Pile Up
Question
Answer
Receiving multiple rental applications can feel overwhelming, but a structured approach helps you select a reliable tenant quickly and fairly. By applying consistent screening criteria and documenting each step, you reduce risk and comply with Fair Housing rules.
Follow these key steps to handle several applications at once:
- Set a clear deadline
Announce a firm cut‑off date for submissions—typically 3–5 days after listing. This ensures you review all applicants at the same time. - Use a uniform application form
Require every prospect to fill out the same form, covering income, employment, rental history and references. You’ll compare apples to apples. - Establish objective screening criteria
Decide beforehand on minimum credit score (e.g., 620+), income ratio (rent ≤ 30–35% of gross income) and acceptable background check results. - Order credit and background checks
Run each applicant through the same reporting service. Expect a cost of \$25–\$50 per file—factor this into application fees if allowed by state law. - Verify rental and employment history
Contact previous landlords and current employers. Look for timely rent payments, property care and steady income over the past 12–24 months. - Score each application
Assign points for credit, income, references and length of tenancy. A simple spreadsheet helps you rank candidates objectively. - Communicate promptly
Notify your top choice and request a holding deposit. Then inform other applicants when you’ve filled the unit, returning any fees according to local regulations.
Throughout the process, maintain detailed records—application dates, screening results and correspondence—to demonstrate fair treatment under the Fair Housing Act. Avoid subjective factors and focus on documented facts.
Before finalizing, it’s advisable to review your state’s landlord‑tenant laws or consult a licensed property manager or attorney. Proper documentation and clear communication protect you from disputes and help you welcome a dependable tenant.
